Importing etc.
Friday, April 10th, 2009 02:06 pmHuh, discussion on the dw-discuss ML regarding the desire of some people to import communities is getting quite passionate.
The issue (for those of you who don't read the ML) is that currently DW allows people to import personal journals, but the importer cannot import communities. This is because it is legally dubious to for a maintainer to import entries which legally belong to someone else.
Now, DW does allow you to import comments made by other people, but because openID allows people to delete their comments, if they so desire, then it isn't as much of a legal issue. But since openID accounts cannot make posts (on a technical level), then there is no way to do something similar with a community. In any event, it also seems like people would be much more incensed about their posts in a comm being imported sans explicit authorization.
Personally, I chose not to import because if I ever need to reference an old post, I can reconstruct it from my LJarchive. Since I can't search my old entries, it would still be difficult to find even if I did import.
The issue (for those of you who don't read the ML) is that currently DW allows people to import personal journals, but the importer cannot import communities. This is because it is legally dubious to for a maintainer to import entries which legally belong to someone else.
Now, DW does allow you to import comments made by other people, but because openID allows people to delete their comments, if they so desire, then it isn't as much of a legal issue. But since openID accounts cannot make posts (on a technical level), then there is no way to do something similar with a community. In any event, it also seems like people would be much more incensed about their posts in a comm being imported sans explicit authorization.
Personally, I chose not to import because if I ever need to reference an old post, I can reconstruct it from my LJarchive. Since I can't search my old entries, it would still be difficult to find even if I did import.